Lies of P

this is my first souls game and until now its top 5 game of all time for me

8分 佳作：“自我素在低语”

Peak

I wanted to like this game, I really did. It starts very strong, an interesting narrative with a very engaging initial trek through Kratz. Unfortunately at some point it seems the development team adopted the idea that they must out BS DS no matter the cost, and it ends up ruining this otherwise compelling offering. Lies of P spends the first 5 or so 'chapters' setting itself up very well, then quickly turns the tight narrative and engaging scenery into a literal torture chamber that leaves you longing for the days of running along tight ropes back in Anor Londo while knight archers shoot great bows at you. I don't know why, but the difficulty ramps up and it ramps up in the worst possible way. Platforming and deliberately targeting weak points in the players toolkit. Whereas the magic of DS is the designers ability to make their shenanigans feel like it's your fault, (practically originating the 'get good' meme) this game very blatantly leaves it obvious that the designers are just F'ing with you on purpose. The primary source of such occurrences is the ridiculous amount of platforming for platforming's sake. At some point it no longer feels like the game you started playing and feels more like a Mario game with all the jumping and tight rope walking. Even DS left most of it's platforming perils to Blight Town and Anor Londo. But the more stand out example of the game grating on nerves is the decision to eliminate the very idea of poise. Any enemy, anytime will 100% interrupt your attacks, there's almost no trading of blows in this game. Which wouldn't normally be a problem on it's own, but they had to give even legless puppets crawling along the ground range that's far greater than even your longest range melee weapons. Unarmed foes can literally hit you with their bare fists from almost half a screen away. And these are the ORDINARY foes. The bosses are an entirely different level of BS and all boil down to having the ability to both attack and retreat entire screen lengths at a time. All this is topped off with the decision to give every enemy (even basic 'trash' enemies) the ability to suddenly turn red and bypass your guard/ability to block. And most can do this with seemingly no limit, especially large 'sub boss' type enemies. There's much more, like every weapon feeling like slapping the enemy with a wet noodle even when fully upgraded, to Stamina being hard capped much lower than in similar games to deliberately amplify the issue mentioned above with the lack of poise. I was hoping this game would turn around, but it never does. It starts off very strong in my opinion but then just jumps off a cliff into one of it's own many fall hazards. In short: Pros: Very unique/beautiful environments. Great tone and setting. Conveys the sense of emotion it's trying to very effectively. Bright welcoming areas like Hotel Kratz work at making you feel at home, while dark, spooky areas like Kratz train station work at creating a dark/tense/scary atmosphere. Tight animations and control feel. Cons: Too much needless platforming, like, wtf? Why are there so many falling hazards in this game? Lack of Poise, makes for a unique combat feel, that unfortunately doesn't feel particularly good. Lack of poise compounded by the fact that pretty much every enemy in the game can bare knuckle outrange you even while you're equipped with a 10 foot long axe made of puppet corpses. Bosses are on a whole nother level of BS. Each one can generally attack from a screen away and retreat an entire screen, often in the same motion. The one stat that can somewhat offset these failings (stamina) is deliberately limited. (+1 stamina after 30 points? REALLY?) So much so that you often find yourself running out of stamina just blocking a boss attack then running across the screen to just get in range of the stupid thing to slap it with your wet noodle weapon that's rapidly running out of durability. This ended up being one of the only games I spent this much time with that actually makes me feel like it was wasted time as my problems with it only get worse the longer the game goes on, not better and by the end I just wanted to be over with it already.

无力了，没有玩明白，[spoiler] 后面二见黑兔帮车轮战就算了，其他人还时不时扔一点投掷物恶心一下你，离得近了其他人也要打你，还要附魔，没两下就要被电击。 [/spoiler]这个游戏推图很简单，就是在boss战方面策划不知道为什么很有想法和创造力

Challenging game play, slightly reminds me of bloodborne, decisions you make alter end result of the game.

didn't finish this game yet but that far it's great I love it

I am not a fan of souls like games but i cant stop playing lies of p. I even played it on legendary stalker difficulty first run and when i finished the game it was glorious. 10 out of 10 game. Also the art and style of the game are astonishing.