The Séance of Blake Manor

This game could have easily been a frustrating mess. I find many games these days are mundane, as if you are working, working towards completing nothing in a loop.

прекрасная игра, понравились истории персонажей, тайны и внезапные их раскрытия. прекрасная озвучка, очень круто обыгран ирландский фольклор, главный злодей вообще не очевиден. жаль Валтера - впрочем, вероятно, правильнее сказать, что жаль Джонатана. было бы круто приехать погостить в таком особняке :)

Esse jogo é um dos melhores jogos de mistério em que você busca as pistas e tem registros para resolver os problemas que já joguei. Acho muito bem feita a esquematização de informações que se obtém sobre os durante o jogo, pois ela mostra os dados que você tem, como os obteve, e a forma como elas são usadas nas mecânicas de resolução é bem feita. Com certeza uma obra que representa muito bem o papel de um detetive de forma organizada, intuitiva e divertida.

E' uno dei giochi più belli a cui abbia giocato ultimamente: bella trama, bella dinamica di gioco, grafica originale, ambientazione strepitosa e accuratamente inserita nel periodo storico...che dire? L'ho giocato tutto d'un fiato e anche avendolo dovuto ricominciare daccapo a un certo punto non mi sono annoiata. Fantastico!

You are invited to investigate the disappearance of a lady named Evelyn Deane. The disappearance of the young woman is intertwined with an event that will take place at Blake Manor in three days: a séance of an unprecedented nature, in which it is expected that a ghost will manifest and speak to those present without the intervention of mediums. The game features just over 25 characters, each with unique stories and motivations. [b] Positive:[/b] [list] [*]Variety of characters and of the subjects they talk about. The historical, mythological, and religious aspects, as well as the different nationalities, were brilliantly integrated into a very cohesive narrative. [/list] [b] Neutral:[/b] [list] [*]Easy puzzles, and the mysteries menu ends up providing, through its descriptions, some guidance on how to solve them. [*]The absence of fast travel and the fact that the map is a mansion make getting around tedious. However, I understand that this design choice is related to events taking place on the map and to being able to hear the characters whispering to one another. The game is not particularly long either, so this does not become a major inconvenience. [*]Some clues lead one to believe that a certain character will have a connection to a mythological being ([spoiler]Walter, a vampire[/spoiler]). There is also no clue (at least as far as I observed) that this character [spoiler]does not actually exist[/spoiler]. As investigative games generally provide players with satisfaction by supplying clues and allowing them to reach conclusions through logical reasoning (as is also the case with mystery novels), the final resolution was surprising to me and made it even more memorable. However, it was not as satisfying. [*]Time restriction: each action consumes 1 minute (with a few rare ones taking longer), creating a concern about being able to solve all the necessary mysteries before the séance at the end of the third day. I personally dealt with this by saving the game, investigating locations or people, and then reloading and performing only the necessary actions. I like exploring dialogue and environments, so, to me, this design choice was controversial. I see that many other players had the same impression. Moreover, I believe it devalues the writers' work, since many pieces of text will consequently go unexplored. Overall, I see it as a negative point, although some people liked it, as the restriction gave the investigation a greater sense of urgency. [/list] [b] Negative:[/b] [list] [*]The obviousness of the culprit for several reasons ([spoiler]it was not possible to solve his mystery, his room would only become available on the third day, he said contradictory things, etc.[/spoiler]). This particular character would have benefited from better writing, or [spoiler]from a “false” mystery that we could solve in order to throw us off the scent[/spoiler], among other things. [*]From the moment you gain access to the characters' rooms, solving the mysteries becomes easy. Many times, you will figure out the solution in your head before you have the clues necessary to actually confront the character. In fact, you cannot even solve some mysteries without access to the room, which I found ignoble. In my opinion, it should be possible to solve the mysteries like a detective, using only relevant questioning and investigation, rather than rummaging through personal belongings as if you had a search warrant. [*]The difficulty of finding characters and the impossibility of visiting them in their rooms. It would be interesting to be able to knock on the door and be invited in, and it would make much more sense than simply invading everyone's rooms or searching the mansion at random for someone in particular. [/list] It is more of a visual novel than an actual investigative game, given that the mysteries are generally obvious. The story itself is not particularly complex or innovative, but I believe it is worth it because the characters are compelling, even those of dubious morality. So, despite having listed only one positive point, that one, in my view, weighed heavily in my recommendation, provided that the negative or neutral points do not bother you too much.

The mystery didn’t hook me as much as I thought it would. In fact, I found myself getting pushed away the more I played. Specifically, the mere presence of a time limit hurt my eagerness to explore, learn, and discuss. It’s uncomfortable that almost all of the interactions with anything cost time, a resource that the game makes a big deal about. Basic observations such as “look in desk” largely lead to a useless “nothing of note in here”. So why build a resource system around these bread and butter interactions? There’s also just a lot of information to sift through and having the game consider the time spent with unimportant conversation or red herrings to be wasted time considerably disincentivizes inquisitiveness. The manor is needlessly sprawling and there are too many submenus (a feature which comes across as a crutch for the overcomplicated, unintuitive puzzles). The characters all seem like oddly generic archetypes, the visuals are generally quite bland, and the mouse sensitivity is messed up. I don’t think I’ll be finishing this one.

I love this game. Not too scary, more of a slow-burn detective story.

Great game. 10/10. Can't recommend it enough.