Strong themes, good experience for the most part. I'm not a huge fan of the way the unreliable narrator thing was done, for me it ended up feeling too convoluted and In need of further explanation. I do like unreliable narrators' if It is done correctly, The Lighthouse is one of my favorite movies. However in a videogame it's much more important that I know the motivations of the character I am following even If the motivations are separate from reality in the narrative. This may have been done to make the "twist" more shocking or to add more discussion after the game is finished but I personally don't think it's worth it to sacrifice a more satisfying experience even if the story is particularly unsatisfying by definition.
Negatives aside it was a very strong piece of story telling that stuck with me. Every time I think about that main menu song it makes me feel something and I think that's the most important part of a story. I just would've liked it more if I didn't have to look up a break down of the whole plot just to understand that the main focus of the game was actually a hidden subplot that had three scenes and at times had moments that intentionally mislead you. If I had to make a few changes I would first make Curly the brother of Jimmy, I would give more dialogue between Anya and Jimmy, remove the cockpit conversation between Anya and Swansea, and in general give the player more time and tools to put the pieces together. No matter how obvious you make it, that last one grantees a more satisfying experience than looking up an explanation ten times out of ten.
You should play it though, just in case it resonates with you.
