Cellar Keeper

На волне успеха «Библиотекаря» пара разработчиков решили поймать удачу за хвост и выпустили ровно то же самое, только про бухлишко. Но, если Вы пытаетесь копирнуть идею – просто слизывать один в один – плохая мысль. Добавьте хоть что-то от себя. Отклеивающиеся этикетки, пиво вперемешку, возможность пригубить бутылочку, что угодно! Тут же полное повторение, которое не дает ничего нового. На этикетках все мелко, ориентируешься только по наименованиям (которые повторяются от сорта к сорту – фантазию даже тут включить забыли) да цвету… в библиотеке хоть названия прикольные были, тут даже улыбнуться нечему. Минус я поставить не могу ровно по одной причине – если б я сначала поиграл в энотеку, а не в библиотеку, подобных претензий у меня б не возникло. Ну и спасибо за приятные ощущения обладания большим погребом вина. Было бы неплохо заиметь что-либо подобное, хотя бы и раз в 10 поменьше.

This game, while similar to "Librarian: Tidy up the Arcane Library!" Is a much-needed addition to the genre. I enjoy the relaxation that cleanup games like this give me, and am eager to see what else this dev comes up with. Solid game, runs fine on my PC, and probably won't take too long to finish. Well worth the 5.99!

В библиотеке есть интересные названия книг, что будоражат фантазию и даже представляешь о чём тут написано. Здесь же по сути ничего, просто типичные названия которые не вызывают вообще ничего.

I was looking forward to playing this, yet after 5 minutes into the actual game I was bored and lost my fun with it. To me it is just lacking.. missing important parts that are for example portrayed in other sorting games.. you get thrown into this without any lore, anything that actually gets you excited.. furthermore you get dropped in, music is on replay and boring, and the design of it is lacking something.. I am not sure as of to what exactly but I know for a fact that it seems more like a fast made and published game rather than it actually having ambience.. it's too bright for my taste and lacks the feel of an old basement or wine storage room.. sorry but I am definitely not convinced nor happy.

TLDR: a lack of creativity and fun (even beyond the use of AI for all the wine labels) and poor execution of the Tidy Up genre Just like many of us I have fallen in love with the soothing pace of a tiny up game. But if you're looking for something to scratch that Tidy Up the Library itch this isn't it. I wanted to like this game as wine is a fun hobby and I could see how it translates to this kind of game well. But there is an extreme lack of fun. The sorting mechanic works fine, it's a Library clone after all. But the labels are tiny so you rely heavily on just reading the word on your carry list and never get that feeling like you know your collection super well. The art and wine names are also super repetitive (the same names and art being used across multiple wines just in different colors), so again, you have to rely on your list. Also ,no whimsy or fantasy really. The overarching "story" has a bit of a gag but that's it. If you're looking for a sorting / tidying game there are a lot better options out there.

Don't get me wrong, if you're just looking for a sorting game to play without any thought to it at all this is for you, but compared to others this was somewhat tedious and boring, since its just wine. There is only so much fun you can have with 3k bottles that all look and are called the same. Good game, unfortunate topic I would say. Don't expect the same humor that you get in "Tidy Up The Arcane Library" if you're from there.

I've had an itch since Librarian: Tidy up the Arcane Library, this game did not satisfy it for me, If you enjoyed that game, you will most likely enjoy this one, however, it just feels like Librarian: Tidy up the Arcane Library, but lacking, more grindy and clunky, and not as immersive as Librarian: Tidy up the Arcane Library. It has no improvement, and it feels like an AI-slop copy, I finished the game, but will not play it again. Why isn't it in a cellar? Spend your money elsewhere.