Cellar Keeper

Feels like walking through mud. Also hard to know where stuff goes because the bottles don't have symbols to match the symbols of where they go. you HAVE TO use the map.

This game was honestly a straight rip off of the Library game. Bar for bar; the setting, the graphics, the powers/perks, and backstory. It just shows a clear lack of an original idea. It was alright to play, but once you get down to the wire, the bottles really blur and look the same. Which made cleaning up hard since it was extremely difficult to tell when you misshelved something. This is probably because generative AI was used for the “design of some fictional bottle brands.” Except I think that most or all of the bottles were generated. For each different type of alcohol, you’d find the same brands with no variation (Example: Orchard Dew Chardonnay and Orchard Dew Cabernet Sauvignon). Quite unrealistic and a missed opportunity to have specific brands for specific types of drinks. Wouldn’t recommend spending your money on this one folks.

Cellar Keeper расслабляющая и уютная игрушка. Вам необходимо рассортировать кучу бутылок по нужным полкам. В вашем распоряжении способности, которые упростят задачу по сортировке. Во втором режиме никаких способностей нет, и это действительно выглядит как испытание. Спокойная музыка позволяет расслабиться и отлично провести время. Разные сорта вина выглядят очень интригующе. Сразу захотелось продигустировать))) Подойдет на несколько вечеров. Игра мне очень понравилась. Рекомендую любителям наводить порядок) P. S. Переименуйте название второго режима. Например, «Испытание без способностей». Оценка 9/10

又一个无法推荐的类图书管理员游戏，只能说如果真的很急着玩的话起码这个相对值得试一下 个人觉得起码做这类游戏起码先想清楚为什么大家乐意玩，总不至于玩家的时间都很不值钱 图书管理员的亮点是找书的同时能通过书名完善魔法世界观，超市的亮点是不同品类的商品摆满货架，明显的从混乱到秩序，而且量大管饱，那我在这里理清一大堆建模相同只有颜色和酒标有差别的瓶子的乐趣是……？ 而且话说回来统一建模只改贴图的技术含量有需要做到8月才出吗？

Compared to other games coming out for the genre like magic library and puzzle library this was more monotonous and the skill upgrades don't feel as nice to play with. The bottle names are repetitive and the colors on the labels is not very different between shelves. It was a fine game that made me sleepy so overall I wouldn't recommend it.

Hepiniz oynayın da akıl hastanesinde koğuş kankisi olalım yalnız kaldım.

This game is directly inspired by Librarian: Tidy up the Arcane Library, and it's basically a reimplementation of the same concept in a different setting. It's absolutely not a "ripoff" any more than all the Nodebuster-like games are ripoffs of Nodebuster. It's just that a very successful game that absolutely nails a niche is going to have other games following the same path. For those of us that love the cozy-tidying-organizing concept, this is a very good thing! For me, Cellar Keeper absolutely scratches that same itch. It nails the atmosphere and brings a high level of visual polish, and imparts that gradual sense of "I can tell at a glance exactly where this goes but I can't really articulate how I know that". That said, there are some pacing and polish issues that I think the dev can and should improve: 1. Power 3 (highlighting matching bottles) and Power 5 (summoning matching bottles) dwarf the other three in utility. This needs some rebalancing. 2. Power 1 is broken; it sorts by bottle number first and _then_ by name, so you get X1, Y1, X2, Y2, X3, etc, which prevents you from rapidly placing X1-3. As a result, I almost never use power 1. 3. The maps are rendered in a different orientation than the room, so reading them is very unintuitive. They both need to be rotated 90 degrees counterclockwise in order to match the orientation of the room - would make them vastly more readable. 4. The overall pacing feels very different / slower than Librarian. Part of this is because it takes a long time to upgrade power 3 and 5 to max, and the relative uselessness of powers 1, 2, and 4. Part of it is because your movement speed is slow. Part of it is because you never develop the intuition about where a bottle will go, unless you're working on that specific shelf, because there doesn't seem to be any natural groupings of the shelves. In Librarian, I knew that the Archery shelf was across from the Swordfighting shelf, and that two camps were humorously opposed to each other. I don't have any corresponding intuition here that varietal X is going to be near varietal Y for reason Z, and there's too many varietals to memorize the locations of all of them without those contextual relationships. 5. The symbols above the bookshelves are an interesting idea, but I don't think it really works long term. I'd like to see some mechanism by which the symbols magically get swapped out for the names after a certain percentage shelf completion. ---- Ultimately, I enjoy this game a lot, and I think it's a great homage to Librarian. I hope and expect to see many other games follow in Librarian's footsteps, bringing their own ideas and tweaks to the formula.

I recently got into these sorting games after the librian game. This is pretty much the same but with wine bottles. One big inconvience for me personally.... I'm Red- Green colourblind so i have difficulty spotting the winebottles. In the librian game you can clearly see the differnce between books, In this one however allot of the wine bottles look the same. I wish the bottles had a more unqiue look to them so its easier to identify them. Other then that complaint i enyoyed my time with it. FIrst playtrough cost me like 5 hours.